Does an HOA Lien Take Priority Over a Mortgage in Utah?
https://jeremyeveland.com/does-an-hoa-lien-take-priority-over-a-mortgage-in-utah/
Usually no. Does an HOA lien take priority over a mortgage in Utah? Not against a first or second mortgage or trust deed that was recorded before the association recorded its notice of lien. Utah Code Sections 57-8a-301 and 57-8-44 put the HOA lien ahead of almost everything else, then carve out exactly three exceptions.
Last updated: August 2026
Key Takeaways
A Utah HOA assessment lien has priority over every other lien and encumbrance on the property except three things: anything recorded before the declaration, a first or second mortgage recorded before the association’s notice of lien, and real estate tax or governmental liens.
The comparison date is the recorded notice of lien, not the declaration and not the date the assessment went unpaid.
Only a first or second security interest is protected. A third-position mortgage, a home equity line sitting in third place, or a judgment lien recorded after the declaration loses to the HOA lien.
The rule is identical for condominiums under Section 57-8-44 and for planned communities and single family HOAs under Section 57-8a-301.
An association that fails to keep its state registration current cannot have a lien arise and cannot enforce one it already has, under Section 57-8a-105.
The right to foreclose is a separate question from priority. A Utah HOA can foreclose while still sitting behind the bank, and a buyer at that sale takes the property subject to the senior mortgage.
Utah HOA and condominium assessment liens are governed by Utah Code Sections 57-8a-301 and 57-8-44.
On This Page
Does an HOA lien take priority over a mortgage in Utah? The direct answer
The Utah HOA lien priority ladder, in order
Why the recording date that matters is the notice of lien
When an HOA lien actually does beat a mortgage in Utah
Condominiums and planned communities: same rule, two statutes
What a Utah HOA lien actually covers
Interest, late fees, and how a small balance grows
An unregistered association may have no lien at all
Foreclosure rights and lien priority are different questions
The Utah HOA foreclosure timeline, step by step
What happens to the mortgage after an HOA foreclosure sale
Payoff demands, closings, and the $50 rule
What to do if you are dealing with an HOA lien in Utah
Common mistakes people make with HOA lien priority in Utah
How a Utah real estate attorney helps
Key Utah statutes on HOA lien priority
Frequently asked questions
Does an HOA Lien Take Priority Over a Mortgage in Utah? The Direct Answer
Utah law gives homeowner associations a strong lien and then immediately narrows it. Section 57-8a-301(4) says a lien under that section “has priority over each other lien and encumbrance on a lot” with three exceptions:
A lien or encumbrance recorded before the declaration is recorded.
A first or second security interest on the lot secured by a mortgage or trust deed that is recorded before a recorded notice of lien by or on behalf of the association.
A lien for real estate taxes or other governmental assessments or charges against the lot.
Exception two is the one that answers the question for most homeowners. In a typical Utah subdivision, the developer records the declaration of covenants, conditions, and restrictions first. A buyer then closes and the lender records a trust deed. Years later the owner falls behind on dues and the association records a notice of lien. That trust deed is a first security interest recorded before the notice of lien, so it stays senior. The HOA lien attaches, it is valid, and it is enforceable, but it sits behind the bank.
“A lien under this section has priority over each other lien and encumbrance on a lot except … a first or second security interest on the lot secured by a mortgage or trust deed that is recorded before a recorded notice of lien by or on behalf of the association.”
Utah Code Section 57-8a-301(4)
Note what Utah did not do. Roughly half the states have adopted some version of a super lien that puts a slice of unpaid assessments, often six months’ worth, ahead of the first mortgage. Utah has no super lien provision in either Chapter 8 or Chapter 8a. The statute protects the first and second security interest in full, not net of a priority window.
The Utah HOA Lien Priority Ladder, in Order
Priority is easiest to read as a ladder. Once you know where each claim sits, the question of whether an HOA lien takes priority over a mortgage in Utah answers itself. Here is how competing claims stack up on a Utah lot or condominium unit.
Position
Claim
Authority
Why it sits there
1
Real estate taxes and other governmental assessments or charges
57-8a-301(4)(c), 57-8-44(4)(c), 59-2-1325
Expressly excepted from the HOA lien. The tax lien attaches on January 1 of each year regardless of recording.
2
Any lien or encumbrance recorded before the declaration
57-8a-301(4)(a), 57-8-44(4)(a)
It predates the covenant scheme entirely, so the HOA lien cannot reach back over it.
3
First and second security interests recorded before the notice of lien
57-8a-301(4)(b), 57-8-44(4)(b)
The purchase money trust deed and, in most cases, the second mortgage or home equity loan.
4
The HOA assessment lien
57-8a-301(1), 57-8-44(1)
Perfected by recording the declaration, senior to everything not listed above.
5
Third and lower security interests, judgment liens, and other later encumbrances
57-8a-301(4)
Not in any exception, so the HOA lien beats them.
One more wrinkle sits outside the ladder. If two or more associations hold assessment liens on the same lot, and the declaration is silent, Section 57-8a-301(6) gives those liens equal priority regardless of when they were created. That comes up in master planned communities where a sub-association and a master association both bill the same owner.
Why the Recording Date That Matters Is the Notice of Lien
This is the single most misread part of Utah HOA lien priority, and it is where most wrong answers to the question begin. Three different dates are in play and only one of them controls the mortgage exception.
Date
What it does
What it does not do
Recording of the declaration
Constitutes record notice and perfection of the association’s lien under 57-8a-301(1)(b). Sets the cutoff for exception (a).
It is not the date used to test whether a first or second mortgage is protected.
Date the assessment came due
Fixes the amount. If assessments are payable in installments, the lien is for the full assessment from the time the first installment is due unless the association says otherwise in a notice of assessment.
It has no effect on priority against a mortgage.
Recording of the notice of lien
This is the comparison date in exception (b). A first or second mortgage recorded before it stays senior.
It is not what perfects the lien. The declaration already did that.
Two consequences follow. First, an association gains nothing on priority by recording a notice of lien quickly against a mortgage that is already on record, because the mortgage recorded earlier either way. Second, an association gains a great deal by recording a notice of lien before a refinance closes, because a refinance is a new trust deed that will be recorded after the notice of lien and therefore falls outside exception (b).
That second point is why title companies chase HOA payoff statements so aggressively. Recording order in Utah is governed by Section 57-3-102, under which a recorded document imparts notice to all persons of its contents from the time of recording. Order on the recorder’s index is the fact that decides the dispute, and it is knowable before closing rather than after.
When an HOA Lien Actually Does Beat a Mortgage in Utah
So far the answer to whether an HOA lien takes priority over a mortgage in Utah has been no. There are real exceptions. The statute protects a first or second security interest. It does not protect a third. That distinction quietly decides real cases.
Scenario one: the third position loan. An owner has a purchase money trust deed, a home equity line of credit in second position, and a later hard money loan in third position. The association records a notice of lien. The first and second are protected. The third position lender is not in any exception, so the HOA lien is senior to it. If the association forecloses, the third position lender is a junior lienholder whose interest can be extinguished by that sale.
Scenario two: the post notice refinance. The association records its notice of lien in March. The owner refinances in June and the new lender records a trust deed. The new trust deed was not recorded before the notice of lien, so exception (b) does not cover it. Lenders manage this risk by requiring an HOA payoff and a lien release at closing, which is exactly why the payoff demand rules discussed below matter.
Scenario three: the judgment creditor. A credit card company records a judgment lien against the owner after the declaration was recorded. A judgment lien is not a security interest secured by a mortgage or trust deed, so it does not fit exception (b) at all. The HOA lien outranks it.
Scenario four: the pre-declaration encumbrance. A utility easement or an old deed of trust was recorded on the raw ground before the developer recorded the declaration. Exception (a) protects it outright, regardless of position or type. Disputes about what was recorded when, and about whether an interest survived, are frequently cleaned up through a quiet title action in Utah.
Condominiums and Planned Communities: Same Rule, Two Statutes
Utah runs community associations through two parallel chapters. Which one applies depends on how the project was created, not on what the building looks like.
Question
Condominium (Title 57, Chapter 8)
Planned community or HOA (Title 57, Chapter 8a)
L